Can Dad Decide the Color of Baby’s Room?

When a new baby joins the family, it’s normal for the couple to go through a re-organization of roles. A common struggle has to do with power and control. Who makes the decisions? About what? Who has “final” say about parenting? This often crops up in arguments about seemingly petty things; but they don’t FEEL petty while we’re in the midst of the struggle. I can’t tell you how many times I argued with BabyShrink’s Hubby about how often the stupid Diaper Genie needed to be changed. See reader Amy’s question below for a similar struggle.Baby Painting

Dear Dr. Heather,

My husband and I are disagreeing over what color to paint our impending child’s room.

In a nutshell, this is the disagreement: I want to paint the room pale green; my husband wants to paint it orange. Yes, orange. I told my husband that orange is too vibrant for a baby’s bedroom, that orange is a color that will stimulate the mind – possibly too much. The last thing I want is (another) child who won’t sleep, and if there’s a chance orange will enable or worsen daytime sleep problems, I do not want orange. He says it would be a light orange – but not peach – and that I’m crazy.

Thank you in advance for any help you can offer.

Sincerely,

Amy, www.thetextureofthings.com

Hi Amy,

It is possible your baby MAY have some preference or reaction to a paint color, but not likely until she can look around and focus her eyes, and then only if she has a sensory issue. You won’t know until you learn about your new baby’s temperament.

But what I think is even more important (and probably the underlying issue?) is the question of Who Makes the Decisions About This Baby? Mom or Dad? Perhaps your hubby is simply looking for a way to feel he is contributing to the decisions being made about the baby. Many Dads feel pushed to the side; like they are “chopped liver” in the parenting department. Taking A Stand on a little issue like paint color might be the way he is asserting his parental authority; saying he cares about what happens when the baby arrives, and wants to be involved.

Dads often feel helpless and useless with a new baby. I remember a friend of ours, a tough guy named Zak. True story: Zak was “all guy”, from old-school Boston. When he and his wife had their first baby, we asked him how it was going. “My wife does everything….feeds the baby, changes him, bathes him…all he wants is her. I want to help so badly, but it seems like there’s nothing I can do. Last night I felt so frustrated I just went and sat in my truck and cried.” We still have a good chuckle over the image of poor tough-guy Zak, crying in his truck.

But the message is poignant: Dads want to contribute…need to contribute…can contribute, in very meaningful ways.

Now I know that sometimes, their efforts can be…well, let’s say, a little misguided. (I mean, seriously, orange?! I feel your pain!) But maybe this is an opportunity to make sure Dad has his say, and is made to feel like a partner in making important parenting decisions about this baby. It’s an issue that will crop up over and over again while your baby grows through different developmental stages…a dance you and your hubby will continue to do together.

But the bottom line is, your baby will benefit from Dad’s full participation, even if her room is day-glo orange.

Good luck, and happy painting!

Aloha,

Dr. Heather

The BabyShrink

Related Posts with Thumbnails

6 Responses to Can Dad Decide the Color of Baby’s Room?

  • Before we had our daughter, we didn’t know what we were going to have (boy or girl)…While looking at paint colors in Home Depot or Lowe’s hubbie pointed out orange too and we wound up doing it. I LOVE IT!!! We used two different shades of a sherbet color orange and separated it with a white chair rail and it’s the most beautiful room (in my opinion). Here is a link to the picture of the room on flickr. http://flickr.com/photos/lilfoot2007/355006195/in/set-72157600315506762/

    Orange doesn’t have to be loud and obnoxious, it can be as pretty as any baby shade of any other color. It’s all in the artistic eye!

  • TracyWI says:

    I remember my hubby feeling like Zak. My oldest breastfed and the little stinker would NOT take a bottle so he couldn’t help with any feedings.

    He did do diaper changes and help him a lot. But there was that “I want to do more to contribute” feeling.

    When my son was weaned my hubby said, “can I do bath and bedtime now that he doesn’t nurse himself to sleep?” I said “YES, YES, YES, YES” while jumping up and down and giggling. LOL

    The boys are now 9 and 6 and they bathe themselves, but Dad does the getting them moving in the right direction and still puts them to bed. If he’s gone for whatever reason and I have to do bedtime, the boys look at me like an alien has taken over their routine!!

    So, I’m curious, how did Zak find his niche in being involved? Don’t leave us hanging!!

  • TracyWI says:

    UGH, that should read “play with him a lot” not “help him a lot”

  • ilima says:

    If you can compromise on a toned-down shade of orange, I vote for giving in on this one. Bottom line: an involved dad will have more impact on the baby’s life than the color of the nursery.

  • Dr. Heather says:

    TracyWI:

    Zak never gave up on anything! He did great, once his wife discovered that she could rely on him to give the baby a bottle once in awhile, and to bathe baby as well. Before we knew it, they had a second baby, and THEN Zak was indispensable!
    ;)

  • amy says:

    Oh my gosh, I cannot believe the bad timing on my part! I’ve had drastically reduced to no internet access for the last two weeks, and I only just now found my question posted!

    First, I appreciate that a dad is often left out (and I love the Zak story), but I think I didn’t describe our partnership enough. My husband is quite involved. Does that mean he feels like he’s involved enough, especially in the big stuff? That ends up being a matter of personal perception, and the lesson I will take from this is that I should be mindful to ask him about it when we come to a disagreement.

    Now let me offer an update. Shortly after I posed my question, Dr. Heather emailed me in response. I gave what she said some thought and I realized two things:
    1. My husband hijacks all things decorating in the house because he worked in an upholstery shop as a young man and because he’s generally more picky than me about decor, so why was I surprised about this?
    2. I totally wasn’t going to win this one, and ultimately that didn’t matter. Honestly, I just wanted the room painted already. I mean, I’ve got nesting to do and our inability to agree on a middle name will have more lasting significance than the room color.

    Here is where I will skip the part of the saga where he was convinced that the best compromise would be to do pale green on the bottom of the wall and orange on the top.

    So he painted it orange – a slightly toned down kool-aid orange but not quite sherbet. Until we put the blinds in the window, I have to say I was worried about how the room glowed like the lights were on ALL THE TIME. Now the blinds are in and the room is positively dark during the day and, I have to admit, it is prettier than I thought it could be. As soon as I get some pictures off of my camera, I’ll post them to my blog and come back here to add a link.

    Thanks, everyone!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Aloha, I’m Dr. Heather

Aloha, I’m Dr. Heather

I'm a psychologist and Mom of four, here to make parenting easier -- and more fun. My advice is science-based and road-tested in the real world. I specialize in babies and young children through age 7. I'm also a parenting writer, national speaker, child development expert, and social media strategist.

Let’s Get This Potty Started!

"Calling all parents who are about to embark on the wild adventure of potty training their child—this is your must-read! With authoritative practical advice, playful tips, and a spirit of connection and love, Dr. Wittenberg gives us an easy-to-read gem of a resource that can lead your family to a diaper-free finish line with minimal fuss -- and a big helping of laughter. Enthusiastically recommended."

Anthony T. DeBenedet, MD, co-author of The Art of Roughhousing: Good Old-Fashioned Horseplay and Why Every Kid Needs It

Dr Heather on Video

Dr. Heather on TV

Pull-Ups Potty Training Ambassador

BabyShrink’s Thoughts

Frequent Topics