Help! Another Kid’s Mom Upset My Kid

Help! Another Kid's Mom Upset My KidBoy, this election is sure making people crazy (me included). Everyone’s all wound up about the outcome, and what it means for us. It’s one of those times when major world events come into the awareness of young children. Usually, we shield them from the daily news and it’s usual dose of murder, theft and intrigue. But huge, long-lasting events like war, hurricanes and contentious national elections creep into the consciousness of our children, and we need to help them understand these events — in a developmentally appropriate way.

It ain’t easy.

My friend Brook has some experience in explaining the realities of hurricanes to her kids, since they live in Florida. But she was shocked when another parent went totally out of line and made a “religious/political” statement to her 6-year-old son. I guess what happened is a group of parents in the Playgroup were discussing politics. Then another parent told the kids, “We don’t like Barack Obama, because he kills babies.”

Umm…EXCUUUSE me?

Now, BabyShrink is not the forum for getting into the evil politics behind this kind of statement (but I sort of can’t help myself). I CAN comment on how and why this kind of statement is developmentally inappropriate — and dangerous — to make to a young child.

First of all, a 6-year-old doesn’t understand the religious/political agenda behind such a statement. He doesn’t know that the parent was referring to abortion, or what abortion is. He couldn’t possibly understand the complex scientific and political and religious arguments on either side. And he won’t really begin to be able to START to grasp it until middle school. That’s just developmental fact.

All he knows is that a man who might become president kills babies…at least that’s what a grownup told him. And killing anything is bad…killing cute things like his baby sister is even worse. Scary, shocking and upsetting. Grownups, especially people in leadership roles, are supposed to be dependable, safe, and caring. Making a comment like that undercuts a child’s very foundation; his ability to trust the adult world.

I know many of my readers are with me so far. But now you’re asking, “How the heck do you RESPOND, in a situation like that? What do I tell my child, the next time some idiot adult says something like that?”

It’s tempting to try to protect our kids — especially the little ones — from the harsh realities of life. The fact is that wars, hurricanes, idiot adults, and other terrible things happen. And we SHOULD protect them from these realities, at least until they have the cognitive capacity to begin to understand, and cope with them. But when we have no choice, we need to respond in a developmentally appropriate way, and only with as much information as your child seeks.

For instance, a toddler or preschooler is pretty clueless about the outside world, and when she does get a glimpse of it, she’s likely to interpret it in a sort of storybook/fantasy way. She’s familiar with the “good guys” and the “bad guys” from fairy tales, so stick with that analogy. Keep things simple, and limited to 1-2 short sentences. And end on an upbeat note, reminding her that she is fine, you are going to keep her safe, and everything will be OK.

But after kindergarten, kids start to become more tuned in to the outside world, and they can understand more about the difference between fantasy and reality. And with that understanding comes the realization that adults maybe aren’t so perfect after all; adults can have failings, make mistakes, and do bad things.

So I advised Brook to explain to her son that the other parent said something mean and untrue, and that Barack Obama DOES NOT kill babies, or anyone, for that matter. And to explain why, as parents, they like him very much. And that perhaps the other family was not a family they would be spending much time with anymore, since “we like to spend time with people who make us feel good, not people who scare us.”

Most importantly, we need to control our own reactions when things like that happen. Because our children take their cues on how to react directly from us. Wisely, Brook kept her cool in that situation (and deserves a gold star, at least!). If she had lost it, the impact on her son would have been far more negative. Because our kids don’t care much about what OTHER parents do. They care about what WE do.

The good news is, a stupid comment like that is likely to be soon-forgotten by a 6-year-old, if it’s handled well by his parents.

But I bet the composition of the Playgroup will be a little different, from now on!

Related Posts with Thumbnails

8 Responses to Help! Another Kid’s Mom Upset My Kid

  • mamabigdog says:

    Five Gold Stars for Brook! And five more for you, BabyShrink, for such a terrific and measured response.

    Regardless of your political affiliation, making statements like that to a 6 YO child is flat out irresponsible, damaging and manipulative. Why someone feels the need to manipulate a small child for political purposes is beyond me. It’s the ultimate bully tactic, and the parent who made that statement should be ashamed of herself.

    As for me, while I admire Brook for her restraint, I would have likely given that parent a sizable piece of my mind, hopefully with the children safely ensconced in the car with the radio on.

    The playgroup will be different indeed…

  • Crystal says:

    I might have snapped at the mom and not only cut her out of playgroup, but yelled at her about the appropriateness of that. Privately I would have then held forth on the evils of McCain to her.

  • amy says:

    Politics aside, when I read this exchange, I immediately thought of an observation my husband made when our daughter was a baby. His mom was over, and my husband pointed out that she would use the baby to talk to us. By this, I mean that in the middle of a conversation with us (adults), grandma would turn and say to the baby (in baby talk) exactly what she would have said to us at that point in the conversation had the baby been absent. It didn’t even matter if the baby was asleep or awake. Sometimes it was so pervasive as to make the conversation difficult to follow. At this point, my husband would call her back to us by joking something to the following effect: “You know, mom, it’s okay to talk directly to us. We don’t bite.” It usually worked. :)

    Although I can’t imagine exactly how I would have reacted to this clearly false and inflammatory statement (whomever you support – Obama does not himself kill babies), I hope that I would have been able to keep my cool because clearly this parent couldn’t manage that.

  • Ilima says:

    Unbelievable.

  • Donna from Kansas says:

    OK, my election/kid story is a little funnier. A very Republican friend of mine (we agree to disagree, no harm no foul) whose son is in my older son’s class calls me last night. She says that my son told her son that John McCain was going to die in three days! And that her son assured her that my son is “always right!” She could barely contain her laughter as we tried to imagine where this little tidbit had originated. So later I asked my son if he had heard any rumors about John McCain (and at this juncture, I am actually greatful that he even knows who John McCain is, something many of my high school students do NOT!). He says that yes, McCain is going to die of cancer in three days! The source–another nine-year-old in his class. So like a game of telephone gone awry, poor John McCain is obviously doomed before the election even gets here.

  • Momo Fali says:

    I have a close family member who talks like that around my kids, even though I’ve made it pretty clear that it’s wrong. Some people get so wrapped up in their own beliefs that they forget we’re all in this together.

  • patricia says:

    Baby Shrink, is everything okay? Should I stop checking for updates? I hope not, but I hope all is well.

  • Dr. Heather says:

    HI PATRICIA!

    I’m working on a new post now. Thanks for checking — everything’s fine! Look for something big soon, too — and have a great weekend!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Aloha, I’m Dr. Heather

Aloha, I’m Dr. Heather

I'm a psychologist and Mom of four, here to make parenting easier -- and more fun. My advice is science-based and road-tested in the real world. I specialize in babies and young children through age 7. I'm also a parenting writer, national speaker, child development expert, and social media strategist.

Let’s Get This Potty Started!

"Calling all parents who are about to embark on the wild adventure of potty training their child—this is your must-read! With authoritative practical advice, playful tips, and a spirit of connection and love, Dr. Wittenberg gives us an easy-to-read gem of a resource that can lead your family to a diaper-free finish line with minimal fuss -- and a big helping of laughter. Enthusiastically recommended."

Anthony T. DeBenedet, MD, co-author of The Art of Roughhousing: Good Old-Fashioned Horseplay and Why Every Kid Needs It

Dr Heather on Video

Dr. Heather on TV

Pull-Ups Potty Training Ambassador

BabyShrink’s Thoughts

Frequent Topics